Nominee for Failed Bread of the Year
This bread had everything right in principle. I had read several recipes in books and online for a yeast bread using pumpkin puree and decided to use the collected ideas and do it my own way. However I made one silly but crucial mistake. Try to guess what it might have been.
Recipe
For two loaves
100 g rolled oats (ground for 30 seconds) (~1 cup)
138 g bread flour (~1 cup)
412 g whole wheat flour (~3 cups)
1½ tsp instant yeast
14 g salt (2 tsp)
32 g brown sugar (3 Tbsp)
1 tsp ground ginger
¾ tsp ground cardamom (5 pods)
73 g orange juice (¼ cup)
389 g pumpkin puree (1 cup)
27 g vegetable oil (2 Tbsp)
2 eggs
134 g whole wheat flour (~1 cup)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiTLe000pl0NCSFZEGkICO0u5-vfVHwPv1V1ofetVNeJxQ5lbkVJIGWQaOrlRwPYGdbwm7FHwpDEYHXRoa3qDqNSpoMoexlLgMsgOlFMYNq1TPdN1KOwT6lXDkn2vSWlcsRuWR-hKBVz90Z/s400/2011_12_04_FailedPumpkinBread_001.jpg) |
Ingredients |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhIAgUbG54HhceRw_O3AptgfCMflyPlr7koFSaO6KUeX484fBB_aTZ4rZ8zGU-oZjdISAq8nSYy9QyCIv3ptTDvKLg7GlDYgnIYhE18igq6IwyvvWDnz2qWrc90Q93DpuQN-gePxnLIvKi6/s400/2011_12_04_FailedPumpkinBread_002.jpg) |
Dry and wet ingredients mixed with 1 cup of flour for later mixing |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiE82DKMQcR5QPxcHOazj1xxE43WygAg0oV9s8yyeUDkfTQx-r2LD9a7jj9CvMfUromZFR92rR9Qq0-W5qKY7hNOZZNEYWMcPZaWfUKqhUPUOTV3ZS0xDtq4tIdXjKbBVHwtQ4eBjMsbXY4/s400/2011_12_04_FailedPumpkinBread_003.jpg) |
2:07 pm: Bringing it together |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj2Ka7Q3MV8OADWoZvfz4EtTO4eryMUfuZkqnM9lILOZU7NpaKUzmlsJgKcA4d6UX6Rm4mc2p1B9yZUwN0u7OIEXkITCwLgydXHM4QK8A-oSY79wzS7sm66J2Yeu-n_EXDvVxQIiRsxk4Se/s400/2011_12_04_FailedPumpkinBread_004.jpg) |
2:24 pm: Ready for first rise |
The first rise was not impressive after more that 3 hours. That got me wondering and I realized what I had done wrong. There wasn't much I could do at this point to improve my chances of a good loaf. I decided to go ahead with the baking anyway.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgMH9Dy4XfTRkqHp-LMWVHgxDcLkV482cZDJtEg-ZTYW0R4UKod8Mzav9o3bpjHDMm46Yqzkz1hdWh7aCAVWVgPWUurQ3V6FJ9_XyJ8CVyX4SzpUqdXYZNUZJuDpn4zS-SE5leoeR13rqR4/s400/2011_12_04_FailedPumpkinBread_005.jpg) |
6:25 pm: After second rise |
I wanted to make a braid using
this technique by smitten kitchen. I had also kept aside some butter and brown sugar to use as filling. However with my failed dough and the messy filling, it wasn't easy to shape the dough.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEinmsufscmgQ_tvwYVx2_nNP_FeNDhs4Ce0nMJ9HIonFytY_Wy7Ev-q5qBhNZeU6ZTzG57bVLGIWGMcLvvoVK4aM-QrcgNbt-5m34LGC_ONiSA63DEqnKn-oLJBXlUNU6a-TPWKuDJ6c8wY/s400/2011_12_04_FailedPumpkinBread_006.jpg) |
6:56 pm: Making a braid |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgJ0OS9syTQc5UyoY4dwQk7rXr36S5fkuJcmMmJZH-KGsWPN5m1g6cTeAwxabFDXBu8sW3IJDzL-BmUSyRygtpI8qiN0Pv8RDeOzm6t256t-s-W9kfhVrVenO3hJTMGcl9j6wLF_j3hiQq8/s400/2011_12_04_FailedPumpkinBread_007.jpg) |
7:02 pm: Bumpy braid trying to rise |
The second half of the dough got a second rise before being shaped into a loaf.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhU7dyZAZFDq6XZQVK2lILnXh0ypA-xXWvuA5EiHFa0R-7HK-u6HrDGOK10Yb6AXyxmsQ7nvqkfrcigMAdTts4ymMlJzIcf8JGeLDfSuuFrdbVZgGw4Jwb_kxna5v3QJlWn_lOuYYCJO-cF/s400/2011_12_04_FailedPumpkinBread_008.jpg) |
7:53 pm: Second loaf got regular treatment |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjEbwYwRndOqjgKLfygth56N0kGpE3P_91MBKzve_Daic8GkHvE1Wyp-qCo3YC5e2um5tqljGwQ-dv1dao3qeLRm8APEU3LZ48u5VSin8krwfdubeffNp2mZXdwjmgj-NSFM1ORZpoooQNY/s400/2011_12_04_FailedPumpkinBread_009.jpg) |
8:30 pm: Not an impressive rise |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhd7Sgb30IfWGLIERQC33kl0xl-cil4Xy3e3zYIwirobQ4ykza5SQIlvD2IqV4qKzqMNDCL2NI6adhifoQUN_AE7urTvFHxR78s5PVmHpw0fN6J5yhKMdQrWvTKe2Yb0G0ubKbqDGfnItju/s640/2011_12_04_FailedPumpkinBread_010.jpg) |
Post baking and after the braid lost a couple limbs to taste testers |
Any guesses about what might have gone wrong?
Here goes: I had used whole wheat pastry flour instead of whole wheat flour! I store both bags in similar containers, and had picked the wrong one.
Can't have a post with only failures to note. So here are pictures from a holiday baking attempt.
Stained Glass Cookies
I made these cookies from a
recipe on Simply Recipes.They were made to share at a Holiday Gift and Recipe exchange with some girlfriends. Mine look nowhere as pretty as the ones Elsie has in her post, but they weren't too bad.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjvZiuMev3eSP9RQl7Dj9cVhEgGtIIzJvhAaJ-Zu8O0j_ybrEC-FoFoOyAnTxp9tnMJBAJM0PEC2Klw3eOcTE9_VSqZue_ox-IFK13WMTijJ5w1vBL3WZ1B1l4sTL5s8jHduYq-S5jxdEvz/s400/2011_12_10_StainedGlass_001.jpg) |
Ingredients and materials |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhmRb5aqdffKG45mK4xChzU9LYHWEkRbRSdQlMnCFq5HeLhu7hPKB_k1FkY2EYWpvg4bf2ikfiaA6SC1j7B8g12JDfISB273qjTME33Z4EbbGsFslV5q0CIZHHCOpMzBFBxQY30kNEIZeJO/s400/2011_12_10_StainedGlass_002.jpg) |
Crushing the LifeSavers |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgaFdPhxSoBL4UfipPb6PCA1Tmm6yLmDOzJNGhpUvnns4Y6muiQ023RMHdGJrqsrzJiX2Jt4SqYeJe-doL7AjUr4dhjUGFevPykiGlvnhlDWgWHgipyYKIpEy_mVKGnD9EqIx_YVj0HPSDk/s400/2011_12_10_StainedGlass_003.jpg) |
Cutouts filled with crushed hard candy |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjoJwchdsRUDC9feI0LaqPL4XWI15VR_4bqOQjxrR6Wa5pRoiG6gEyrYEdSNkpugNVe2MSQrTS9LCnT1C-68r15ux5Ps3blhfBaF08DP1NN0DlkhwLAFwwlV_eDCKARQ2rENts2dr7lKuvL/s400/2011_12_10_StainedGlass_004.jpg) |
Cooling |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjGRAOmuW99rJAZ_FC7HdpBTiZ9JYisMKPwYQZn8B9_Dwp5aQ3xZEzOTL7GJcmALuzRF41JBF5xAtGOdnaZbgGalOTKauDumiDXkLVh_wO7euu90o0lVDkFB06Q8a_oCjfhVua_1ZJQ9uwi/s400/2011_12_10_StainedGlass_005.jpg) |
The stained glass effect! |
Happy Holidays!
-RPH